Peculiar Posting: Agency Owner Finds Rodent Tooth in Food
If you check out the Insurance Journal every day, you've probably seen this latest story—it's one of IJ's most emailed articles this week.
But in case you missed it, apparently the owner of a St. Louis-area insurance agency is suing Kraft Foods Inc., claiming that he found a rodent tooth in a package of Planter's peanuts.
I have to tell you, as a person who's particularly sensitive about food preparation, this was hard for me to read. A couple years ago when I was still in college, the wife of a professor found a lizard head in her Applebee's salad. I thought I'd recovered nicely from the 2003 incident. And now this.
According to IJ, the lawsuit alleges that Carl Cornett bought a package of Planter's peanuts (packaged by Kraft) at an O'Fallon, Ill. store last August. He was eating them at home when he bit into a "non-human animal tooth." Cornett's lawyer said the tooth looks like it was from "an herbivorous rodent of some type".
Cornett says he became physically and mentally ill at the thought that he could have exposed himself to some kind of disease. The herbivorous rodent kind of disease. Cornett's lawyer said that Kraft asked him to submit the tooth for testing. The lawyer declined that request—he didn't want to part with the evidence.
Now, I'm as grossed out by this as anyone else but I'm a little concerned about the fact that the plaintiff was enjoying a package of peanuts from last year. I assume they were never opened but I also assume that peanuts have a shelf life.
In fact, according to Feridies, [World's Best Peanuts and Specialty Foods], peanuts in cellophane bags have a shelf life of only four to six weeks! Assuming a store-bought bag of Planter's peanuts counts as cellophane storage, those peanuts went stale eight months ago.
And, upon further research, I learned that peanuts—along with other ground and tree nuts—have the potential to grow Aspergillus and Aflatoxin when stale. Aspergillus and Aflatoxin are a toxic, carcinogenic fungi than can make you really sick if you eat it. As I understand it, aflatoxins are similar to mycotoxins and can result in some pretty serious illness. Like liver cancer, for instance.
Biology and chemistry aside, what I'm saying is that I don't doubt for moment that Cornett got sick from eating that bag of old peanuts. But I'm not entirely convinced it was because he found the tooth of an herbivorous rodent in his snack. Yes, I'll definitely need to see some conclusive test results on the origin of the "tooth".
In closing, I'd like to extend my services to Kraft's defense attorneys. With all the research I've done on aflatoxins today, I think I could be of great help.
[FURTHER READING]:
- A 1999 study of human diseases caused by mold [World Health Organization]
- The science behind aflatoxins [International Research Corps]
- One blogger's take on aflatoxins and how to keep your food fungus-free [Here Be Dragons]








Comments
Anyone willing to eat a very old bag of peanuts should not get upset by the existence of an old tooth. The punishment, if this turns out to be frivolous, should be rodent teeth in all his meals for a month.
Posted by: Jr. | May 22, 2006 02:50 PM
You need to get your facts straight, the penauts were purchased in Nov. 2006 and open to eat in nov. 2006, which was when the tooth was found, NOT 8 months after purchase. And it was a tooth, a large tooth in fact with roots and all.
Posted by: Donna | January 17, 2007 12:35 PM