Daily sales & marketing tips for insurance professionals

Questions? Call (800) 467-8736

Always Be Prospecting

March 13th, 2007 by Megan Mahan

Admittedly, I felt like I’d just gotten
the old bait-and-switch.
But before I knew it,
she was handing me free samples and goody bags.

We’ve talked about ABC–or, Always Be Closing–here on the Agent Blog before. But yesterday afternoon as I stood in line at Kinko’s, I got a lesson in ABP–Always Be Prospecting.

Standing in the inert line at Kinko’s, the woman in front of me started making what I thought was idle conversation, finally saying, “You have great skin. What do you use on it?”

What a compliment! So I spilled my daily skin regimen–product names, everything.

Then, as she was pouring over my pores, she said:


“I’d love to give you my card. I’m a Mary Kay representative and I think you’d really love our products.”

Admittedly, I felt like I’d just gotten the old bait-and-switch. But before I knew it, the woman–Dianne–was handing me free samples and goody bags, all of which she kept handy in her purse.

“Would you be interested in attending a Mary Kay makeover party?” she asked.

I responded with an honest “No.” I did that once in college with a bunch of co-workers; I walked out of that place looking like, well… you get the idea.

“Would you be interested in selling Mary Kay products?”

Again, I told her no. And I was starting to get a tad uncomfortable. But, for blogging purposes, I let her keep on.

“Okay, that’s fine. Why don’t you give me your business card so I can follow up with you next week?”

A-ha. The assumptive close. Valiant effort, but I wasn’t comfortable giving my contact information to a perfect stranger I just happened upon in a Kinko’s line (which still wasn’t moving, by the way.) As it turns out, I’m pretty bad about keeping business cards on me, so I didn’t have to fib to get out of giving her my info.

“Well, my business card is in your goody bag so give me a call next week if you want, and be sure to check out my web site. You can order anything right online.”

Now that I can handle. Put the ball in my court. Let me call the shots.

I checked out her web site last night, and while I haven’t purchased anything yet, the fact that I bothered to look at her site at all should be considered a small win.

What tips should you take away from my encounter with Dianne?

  1. Use casual, genuine conversation to attain clues about the prospect’s buying habits and preferences.
  2. Keep it casual. I would have felt much better if Dianne wouldn’t have pushed me with questions about attending a make-up seminar or selling her products.
  3. Have swag on hand. Keeping a plethora of lip gloss samples probably won’t work for the average insurance agent, but a cool pen or goody bag holding your business card and a $5 Starbucks gift card will make the prospect feel spoiled and give the prospect a way to contact you.
  4. Be careful with the assumptive close. Prospects will be nice to you because their mothers have taught [most of] them the importance of being polite. But Dianne should have taken my “Nos” to heart instead of asking me for my contact information. Had I been more receptive to her offers, asking to follow up with me would have been perfectly acceptable.
  5. Get your [web] act together. I loved that she left me with her web site URL where I could look around all I wanted. Lucky for her it was a good-looking, easy-to-use web site, or I would have bailed within the first 10 seconds. Having a great web site will encourage me to stop back–which increases the chances that I’ll buy something.

There’s my two cents on the encounter. Leave yours via comments!

Share & Enjoy:

Leave a Reply