« Do You Ignore Customer Emails? | Main | Should You Get into Social Media Marketing? »

The Anatomy of Successful Insurance Sites: Part One

You're about to embark on a recap of The Anatomy of Successful Web Sites: Building Trust to Earn Business, as published in the March issue of the TAAR Report. This is part of a series of posts recapping my "TAarticles."


The aesthetics is only one part of building trust with visitors. Successful web sites, like Miss America, bring the total package.

In case TIME Magazine’s person of the year (“You”!) didn’t tip you off, we’re at the crux of a customer revolution. And the World Wide Web is almost solely responsible for it. From communication to commodities, the internet helps today’s consumer get what they need with a few clicks of a button.

The ease and accessibility of the internet has led to growing use in the financial services industry—recent Forrester Research figures showed a rise in online insurance shopping, with 72% of auto insurance shoppers using the web to find a policy. While that figure may not seem particularly noteworthy, what is surprising is that 64% of those shoppers said that a site’s ease of use was “extremely” or “very important” in their selection of an auto policy.

Successful agencies are paying close attention to that 64%, designing sites that exceed visitor expectations. Because when that happens, trust is earned. And while the web may have changed the way we find and buy goods and services, one significant sales tenet has remained constant:

Trust = Relationship = New Business.

Yep. Even on the web.

Building Trust Online

While web use and shopping are up, new reports underscore the need for the financial services industry to design sites for trust. Phishing and online fraud keep people from wanting to give out personally identifiable information like Social Security number, driver’s license number, phone number, even email address.

Everything
on a web site either builds visitor trust or undermines it.

The reluctance to share on the part of the consumer can often cost an agent more time—filtering out fake leads and re-quoting prospects who didn’t feel comfortable providing more specific information the first time around.

Successful agencies are aware of these barriers and design their sites to deal with them from the outset, employing a variety of features most agencies don’t consider.

Successful, trust-building sites:

  • Make it easy for visitors to accomplish their goal (finding information, getting a quote, etc.)
  • Give resources
  • Appear human
  • Reassure visitors
  • Are aesthetically pleasing

That last one may surprise you. After all, weren’t we taught in school not to judge a book by its cover? Newsflash: that doesn’t apply on the web.

Speaking at The Future of Web Apps last fall, Jeff Veen, Google’s user interface designer, said everything on a web site either builds visitor trust or undermines it. The startling statistic: visitors decide whether or not they trust your site in a little as one-twentieth of a second. Which is evocative of another childhood lesson: you only get one chance to make a first impression.

Of course, the aesthetics is only one part of building trust with your visitors. Successful web sites, like Miss America, bring the total package.

Ensuring Privacy and Security

As I prepared to write this article, I asked InsureMe Usability Manager David Lansdon to review a few insurance sites and tell me what was working…and what wasn’t. While he made a handful of great observations, David was most surprised by the lack of attention given to addressing privacy and security measures.

“We know that privacy and security are of primary importance to users—addressing these concerns with links to privacy policies and content explaining why the site needs certain personal information should be foremost in the minds of insurance site owners,” said David. “Combined with explanations of the measures the site takes to secure user information, visitors will be more willing to share.”

One of my favorite books, Hot Text: Web Writing That Works, offers a few more suggestions to use your security and privacy policies as trust-building tools:

Write a privacy policy that’s easy to understand. Spare heavy legal terminology and instead tell visitors how you’re going to protect their valuable info.

Give visitors reason and reward. If you need personal information from a visitor, tell them why—and how it will benefit them.

Don’t pontificate. Keep your security and privacy policies free of marketing hyperbole. It gets in the way of the important stuff.

Make a big deal when a screen goes to a secure server. Let users know when they’ve switched to a secure (https://) server and they’ll be more willing to give you the information you need.

In truth, most of your visitors won’t read your full privacy and security policies. But clearly displaying links and logos will encourage your visitor as they explore your site and build the kind of customer confidence you need to covert the prospect to a new sale.


Stay tuned for part two of The Anatomy of Successful Insurance Sites to learn about the ROI of a trustworthy site!

Comments

Is someone finding auto insurance on the web as popular as someone finding life insurance? I'm going to be taking the state exam for my insurance agent license and i'm trying to find out why the web is becoming more popular than an actual agent

Darius,

Great question.

Here's my answer, in two parts:

(1) Online insurance shopping is on the rise. That's because it's fast, easy, and free. Who wants to spend an afternoon with the yellow pages, calling around town to get insurance quotes? No one.

Insurance shopping web sites also give consumers the opportunity to educate themselves on insurance matters, so they can find the right policy. Giving them the control to do so is a big win for insurance agents.

(2) While online insurance shopping is up—and will stay that way—there are still many people who want to buy from an agent. Shopping sites like InsureMe.com give the best of both worlds: they allow the consumer to shop online and receive multiple quotes from local providers. They also provide the human factor, which has shown to be important to people when purchasing something like life insurance.

The convenience of the web is what makes it more popular than contacting a bunch of agents. But don't mistake the human factor. Most people know that their insurance agent is the person they're going to turn to in case of an emergency, and they want to make sure they're working with a trustworthy partner.

I too, am an independent agent. I have worked for a large internet based life insurance agency. The key that we found to getting customers to our site is advertising. As we say, the internet is not a "Field of Dreams". You cannot have a "just build it and they will come" attitude.

Also, most web-based customers are under the impression that they are going "direct", as in direct to the carrier. This of course is wrong, as you know, an agent is involved somewhere as that is the method of distribution chosen by probably 95%+ of the insurance companies.

The other perceived benefit of the going "direct" idea is that it must be cheaper to cut out the middleman (agent). As life insurance rates are set by the carrier and approved with the state insurance commissioner, very few companies have rates less than their published and regulator approved rates.

Megan, by the way, you guys have a good site for agents, full of good ideas and info.

Holger,

Fantastic comments. You're 100% correct when you say that the internet is not a "Field of Dreams."

Creating a usable, aesthetically pleasing web site is only half the battle. Getting people to your site is another. For tips an ideas about getting people to your site, check out my previous articles for the TAAR Report regarding online marketing for insurance agents.

If you don't have a subscription, you can catch detailed recaps here and here.

Thanks again for stopping by, Holger—and for complimenting our blog. Hope to see you back!

Post a comment