Deed vs. Breed: What Do You Think?
August 28th, 2009 by Penny Hagerman
If you own a home and at least one dog, you probably know your insurance company charges more to insure some dogs than others.
As Jeb so aptly points out in his own, humorous
way, owners of larger dogs like pit bulls known for their aggression pay more to insure against bodily injury than those who own little dogs, like Pomeranians.
“But wait,” you say. “My pit bull is the sweetest, most loving dog ever! How come I have to pay more for insurance than my neighbor with the little pomeranian, when my pittie has never hurt anyone?”
In short, it’s because that sweet 80-pound pit bull’s breed has a not-so-nice reputation. That means he’s a higher risk than the little pomeranian. And insuring against risk means a higher likelihood of claims and higher home insurance rates.
If that 80-pound dog did decide to nip at that little kid he thought was threatening you in the park, he’d be likely to take the child’s face off without thinking twice; whereas that little pomeranian would be more likely to make a lot of noise or run away.
At least, that’s how the ‘Breeds’ side of the argument goes.
Some people think that notion is utterly ridiculous. “Judge a dog on his deeds, not his breed,” they say.
While that sounds good to the human ear, your insurer says it’s just not a reliable method for determining which dog will attack and injure, and which one won’t. Therefore, like it or not, owning that pit bull could end up costing you a lot more money than owning a smaller animal with a less violent history.
What do you think? Should homeowners be charged liability rates based on their dog’s breed or history? Let us know your thoughts—dog owner or not!






Most of us have been seeing unusual weather patterns this year.
We all know that familiar sound: Bleep! It’s another text message that needs our attention.
It’s your worst nightmare (and reminiscent of an Ashton Kutcher movie from a few years back): You drive across town to a friend’s house, park your car across the street, and head over for a rockin’ good time at a party.